Europe’s Mindset on Climate Migration Must Change

Oxfam’s miniature migrant climate camp set up in EU capitals, pictured here is Madrid. “Oxfam reminds EU heads of state what is at stake if they fail to provide new money for poor communities to protect themselves from climate change.” Photo by Oxfam International/ Flickr.

It is estimated that by 2050 there will be 1.2 billion people forcibly displaced because of climate change, yet the climate migrants already fleeing the impacts of rising temperatures currently have no legal method of seeking safety or refugee status in Europe

by Alice Chapman

February 24, 2023

Most of what we associate refugees and migration with is the fleeing of conflict and economic instability. 

Problems that the west have not been particularly sympathetic about over the years, as governments have continuously pressed for harsher regulations surrounding the ability of asylum seekers to enter certain countries. 

However over the past few years, the world has been made increasingly aware of a new cause of migration: climate change, a problem that some may consider the responsibility of the west. 

It has been estimated that 1.2 billion people around the globe will be displaced due to climate change by 2050.

To put this into perspective: That’s over is 15% of the entire world population unable to live in their homeland, due to the impacts of rising global temperatures. 

1 Cup Before Breakfast Chews Up Heavy Fat

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) says that there are currently over 100 million people forcibly displaced around the world, this includes both internal displacement and those who have fled their homeland. 

So to say that climate change is a pressing issue on humanity, is beyond an understatement. 

EU borders are already struggling enormously at present with the millions currently seeking refuge, but to have 1.2 billion people to accommodate worldwide is unimaginable. 

Those who live in fortunate areas that are not yet affected by climate change, will likely feel the political toll taken on huge amounts of people trying to enter their countries from fleeing climate change. 

Sony PlayStation Store 110 - Sony, [Digital]

The political problem of climate migration

The urgent, yet complex issues associated with climate change are becoming increasingly complicated in political terms, as there are currently no international laws for those fleeing from situations caused by its impacts. 

This leaves those fleeing their homelands due to environmental destruction with little to no legal migration options. 

The EU’s refugee laws can be considered somewhat outdated due to this, as the majority of regulations that have been established regarding migration were set before climate change was having a major impact on people’s livelihoods. 

The current political issue is that environmental migrants are not covered by the 1951 Geneva Convention relating to the status of refugees, which only covers those fleeing war and persecution.  

Certain UN agencies are reluctant to officially class those leaving their countries due to environmental issues as “climate refugees,” largely because certain countries do not even have the means to support the existing refugee crisis, as they have already been “stretched to the limit.”

Therefore, there are doubts as to whether expanding the definition of “refugee” to include climate scenarios, would in fact be met with the necessary global political and economic support.

Nina Birkeland, senior adviser for disasters and climate change at the Norwegian Refugee Council, says adjusting or recreating the current refugee convention could take decades.

Other refugee specialists are concerned that if the current treaty was changed to accommodate climate refugees, those who believe the current system is “too generous”would use the opportunity to “dilute current obligations” therefore making the system harsher on those who already have rights. 

Essentially, changing the system with an aim to help a greater number of people, might in fact end up causing further suffering. 

At the UN climate conference COP27, climate change related migration was barely even covered as a topic. In fact, the only visible means of action that the EU has taken is building tremendously sized walls to keep illegal immigrants out. 

Journalists Jennifer Rigby and James Crisp have described this as “Fortress Europe,”affirming the structures that have been built are the equivalent in size to 12 Berlin Walls. 

Is there anything being done to help climate refugees?

The EU aside, New Zealand is set to become the first country to issue climate change-related visas. Former Prime Minister Jacinda Arden created plans for a specific visa for those coming from pacific coast islands that are subject to sea level rise. 

It’s astonishing that New Zealand is the only country in the world to recognise climate change as a reason for movement, but also relieving that at least someone is doing something. However, the scheme only proposes to issue up to 100 visas per year, which is a drop in the ocean compared to the scale of the issue in hand. 

Climate change is moving at such a fast pace that it is considerably difficult for governments to adapt policy and legislation in time to accommodate those in need. However what could be done, is addressing the root of the problem itself, which is something governments have been aware of, but ignored for years (if not decades) – climate change itself. 

Subscribe to our newsletter.

This article was originally published on IMPAKTER. Read the original article.

0 Shares